Skip to main content

National Trends

FMCSA relies on its State partners to provide crash and inspection data each month. Improving the quality of every State’s safety data will result in a more effective use of our Nation’s enforcement resources.
Data current as of February 28, 2020

Crash Consistency Overriding Indicator

National Trends > Measures
No Flag
51

Red Flag
0

Insuf Data
0

The national Crash Consistency Overriding indicator results show the number of States within each rating. A State’s consistency indicator is based on the estimated number of non-fatal crash records reported. The crashes evaluated were first uploaded between 12/01/2018 and 11/30/2019 and were compared to the previous 3 year reporting average. Learn how this rating is calculated.
info
Why this matters

It is important to ensure that all crash records are reported to FMCSA. Crash records are used by the SMS to assess carrier safety performance and prioritize carriers for interventions that pose the greatest safety risk. 

What to do next

Make sure that you understand the Crash Consistency Overriding indicator and the rating.

  • Use the NFCC Tool.
  • Select another measure from the drop-down menu above to view State ratings for that measure
  • Select a State on the map, then click on a measure within the pop-up window to view State-specific results
  • Contact a FMCSA Data Quality Specialist to ask questions

You can also explore other resources in the Help Center.

Crash Consistency Overriding Indicator: Percentage of State-Reported Non-Fatal Crash Records
State Rating Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Avg # Records Reported
over Previous 3 Years
Total # Records
Dec. 1, 2018 - Nov. 30, 2019
Estimate Reported for Current Year
Dec. 1, 2015 - Nov. 30, 2016 Dec. 1, 2016 - Nov. 30, 2017 Dec. 1, 2017 - Nov. 30, 2018
National N/A 172,104 177,846 189,684 179,877 184,630 103%
Alabama Green Circle - No Flag 4,334 4,126 4,747 4,402 4,627 105%
Alabama
Year 14,334
Year 24,126
Year 34,747
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years4,402
Total # Records4,627
Estimate Reported for Current Year105%
Alaska Green Circle - No Flag 63 48 22 44 35 80%
Alaska
Year 163
Year 248
Year 322
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years44
Total # Records35
Estimate Reported for Current Year80%
Arizona Green Circle - No Flag 3,201 3,116 2,760 3,026 2,599 86%
Arizona
Year 13,201
Year 23,116
Year 32,760
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,026
Total # Records2,599
Estimate Reported for Current Year86%
Arkansas Green Circle - No Flag 2,630 2,815 2,683 2,709 2,534 94%
Arkansas
Year 12,630
Year 22,815
Year 32,683
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,709
Total # Records2,534
Estimate Reported for Current Year94%
California Green Circle - No Flag 12,840 13,372 14,306 13,506 14,081 104%
California
Year 112,840
Year 213,372
Year 314,306
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years13,506
Total # Records14,081
Estimate Reported for Current Year104%
Colorado Green Circle - No Flag 2,055 1,856 2,203 2,038 2,264 111%
Colorado
Year 12,055
Year 21,856
Year 32,203
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,038
Total # Records2,264
Estimate Reported for Current Year111%
Connecticut Green Circle - No Flag 2,033 1,768 1,602 1,801 1,509 84%
Connecticut
Year 12,033
Year 21,768
Year 31,602
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,801
Total # Records1,509
Estimate Reported for Current Year84%
Delaware Green Circle - No Flag 610 655 701 655 633 97%
Delaware
Year 1610
Year 2655
Year 3701
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years655
Total # Records633
Estimate Reported for Current Year97%
District of Columbia Green Circle - No Flag 180 192 282 218 217 100%
District of Columbia
Year 1180
Year 2192
Year 3282
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years218
Total # Records217
Estimate Reported for Current Year100%
Florida Green Circle - No Flag 8,892 9,161 10,206 9,420 10,477 111%
Florida
Year 18,892
Year 29,161
Year 310,206
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years9,420
Total # Records10,477
Estimate Reported for Current Year111%
Georgia Green Circle - No Flag 5,816 6,616 6,784 6,405 4,747 74%
Georgia
Year 15,816
Year 26,616
Year 36,784
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years6,405
Total # Records4,747
Estimate Reported for Current Year74%
Hawaii Green Circle - No Flag 169 134 152 152 179 118%
Hawaii
Year 1169
Year 2134
Year 3152
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years152
Total # Records179
Estimate Reported for Current Year118%
Idaho Green Circle - No Flag 725 991 801 839 885 105%
Idaho
Year 1725
Year 2991
Year 3801
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years839
Total # Records885
Estimate Reported for Current Year105%
Illinois Green Circle - No Flag 7,773 7,708 8,206 7,896 4,597 58%
Illinois
Year 17,773
Year 27,708
Year 38,206
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years7,896
Total # Records4,597
Estimate Reported for Current Year58%
Indiana Green Circle - No Flag 5,542 5,565 5,934 5,680 5,332 94%
Indiana
Year 15,542
Year 25,565
Year 35,934
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years5,680
Total # Records5,332
Estimate Reported for Current Year94%
Iowa Green Circle - No Flag 2,017 1,991 2,285 2,098 2,426 116%
Iowa
Year 12,017
Year 21,991
Year 32,285
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,098
Total # Records2,426
Estimate Reported for Current Year116%
Kansas Green Circle - No Flag 1,714 1,667 1,836 1,739 2,020 116%
Kansas
Year 11,714
Year 21,667
Year 31,836
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,739
Total # Records2,020
Estimate Reported for Current Year116%
Kentucky Green Circle - No Flag 3,331 3,226 3,512 3,356 3,342 100%
Kentucky
Year 13,331
Year 23,226
Year 33,512
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,356
Total # Records3,342
Estimate Reported for Current Year100%
Louisiana Green Circle - No Flag 3,998 4,094 4,023 4,038 3,855 95%
Louisiana
Year 13,998
Year 24,094
Year 34,023
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years4,038
Total # Records3,855
Estimate Reported for Current Year95%
Maine Green Circle - No Flag 797 850 971 873 926 106%
Maine
Year 1797
Year 2850
Year 3971
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years873
Total # Records926
Estimate Reported for Current Year106%
Maryland Green Circle - No Flag 3,256 3,377 3,876 3,503 3,798 108%
Maryland
Year 13,256
Year 23,377
Year 33,876
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,503
Total # Records3,798
Estimate Reported for Current Year108%
Massachusetts Green Circle - No Flag 1,732 1,874 1,184 1,597 2,862 179%
Massachusetts
Year 11,732
Year 21,874
Year 31,184
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,597
Total # Records2,862
Estimate Reported for Current Year179%
Michigan Green Circle - No Flag 4,753 5,079 6,109 5,314 6,362 120%
Michigan
Year 14,753
Year 25,079
Year 36,109
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years5,314
Total # Records6,362
Estimate Reported for Current Year120%
Minnesota Green Circle - No Flag 2,410 2,644 2,844 2,633 2,969 113%
Minnesota
Year 12,410
Year 22,644
Year 32,844
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,633
Total # Records2,969
Estimate Reported for Current Year113%
Mississippi Green Circle - No Flag 1,851 1,899 2,002 1,917 1,964 102%
Mississippi
Year 11,851
Year 21,899
Year 32,002
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,917
Total # Records1,964
Estimate Reported for Current Year102%
Missouri Green Circle - No Flag 5,244 5,584 5,882 5,570 6,444 116%
Missouri
Year 15,244
Year 25,584
Year 35,882
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years5,570
Total # Records6,444
Estimate Reported for Current Year116%
Montana Green Circle - No Flag 571 713 816 700 767 110%
Montana
Year 1571
Year 2713
Year 3816
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years700
Total # Records767
Estimate Reported for Current Year110%
Nebraska Green Circle - No Flag 1,219 1,256 1,429 1,301 1,429 110%
Nebraska
Year 11,219
Year 21,256
Year 31,429
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,301
Total # Records1,429
Estimate Reported for Current Year110%
Nevada Green Circle - No Flag 510 669 771 650 762 117%
Nevada
Year 1510
Year 2669
Year 3771
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years650
Total # Records762
Estimate Reported for Current Year117%
New Hampshire Green Circle - No Flag 474 508 534 505 494 98%
New Hampshire
Year 1474
Year 2508
Year 3534
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years505
Total # Records494
Estimate Reported for Current Year98%
New Jersey Green Circle - No Flag 6,566 6,177 7,292 6,678 6,934 104%
New Jersey
Year 16,566
Year 26,177
Year 37,292
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years6,678
Total # Records6,934
Estimate Reported for Current Year104%
New Mexico Green Circle - No Flag 887 920 950 919 977 106%
New Mexico
Year 1887
Year 2920
Year 3950
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years919
Total # Records977
Estimate Reported for Current Year106%
New York Green Circle - No Flag 7,000 7,201 8,546 7,582 8,868 117%
New York
Year 17,000
Year 27,201
Year 38,546
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years7,582
Total # Records8,868
Estimate Reported for Current Year117%
North Carolina Green Circle - No Flag 8,928 7,783 8,333 8,348 7,876 94%
North Carolina
Year 18,928
Year 27,783
Year 38,333
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years8,348
Total # Records7,876
Estimate Reported for Current Year94%
North Dakota Green Circle - No Flag 551 645 649 615 707 115%
North Dakota
Year 1551
Year 2645
Year 3649
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years615
Total # Records707
Estimate Reported for Current Year115%
Ohio Green Circle - No Flag 7,261 7,957 8,128 7,782 7,179 92%
Ohio
Year 17,261
Year 27,957
Year 38,128
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years7,782
Total # Records7,179
Estimate Reported for Current Year92%
Oklahoma Green Circle - No Flag 3,313 3,329 3,707 3,450 3,558 103%
Oklahoma
Year 13,313
Year 23,329
Year 33,707
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,450
Total # Records3,558
Estimate Reported for Current Year103%
Oregon Green Circle - No Flag 1,754 2,075 1,665 1,831 1,864 102%
Oregon
Year 11,754
Year 22,075
Year 31,665
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,831
Total # Records1,864
Estimate Reported for Current Year102%
Pennsylvania Green Circle - No Flag 7,571 8,062 8,586 8,073 8,812 109%
Pennsylvania
Year 17,571
Year 28,062
Year 38,586
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years8,073
Total # Records8,812
Estimate Reported for Current Year109%
Rhode Island Green Circle - No Flag 206 203 218 209 208 100%
Rhode Island
Year 1206
Year 2203
Year 3218
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years209
Total # Records208
Estimate Reported for Current Year100%
South Carolina Green Circle - No Flag 3,068 3,451 3,754 3,424 3,740 109%
South Carolina
Year 13,068
Year 23,451
Year 33,754
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years3,424
Total # Records3,740
Estimate Reported for Current Year109%
South Dakota Green Circle - No Flag 357 327 375 353 394 112%
South Dakota
Year 1357
Year 2327
Year 3375
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years353
Total # Records394
Estimate Reported for Current Year112%
Tennessee Green Circle - No Flag 4,265 4,183 4,432 4,293 4,315 101%
Tennessee
Year 14,265
Year 24,183
Year 34,432
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years4,293
Total # Records4,315
Estimate Reported for Current Year101%
Texas Green Circle - No Flag 16,849 18,331 19,497 18,226 20,276 111%
Texas
Year 116,849
Year 218,331
Year 319,497
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years18,226
Total # Records20,276
Estimate Reported for Current Year111%
Utah Green Circle - No Flag 1,624 1,674 1,786 1,695 1,234 73%
Utah
Year 11,624
Year 21,674
Year 31,786
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,695
Total # Records1,234
Estimate Reported for Current Year73%
Vermont Green Circle - No Flag 202 240 226 223 144 65%
Vermont
Year 1202
Year 2240
Year 3226
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years223
Total # Records144
Estimate Reported for Current Year65%
Virginia Green Circle - No Flag 4,440 4,286 4,500 4,409 4,600 104%
Virginia
Year 14,440
Year 24,286
Year 34,500
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years4,409
Total # Records4,600
Estimate Reported for Current Year104%
Washington Green Circle - No Flag 2,141 2,355 2,258 2,251 2,296 102%
Washington
Year 12,141
Year 22,355
Year 32,258
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,251
Total # Records2,296
Estimate Reported for Current Year102%
West Virginia Green Circle - No Flag 975 1,023 1,170 1,056 1,140 108%
West Virginia
Year 1975
Year 21,023
Year 31,170
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,056
Total # Records1,140
Estimate Reported for Current Year108%
Wisconsin Green Circle - No Flag 2,445 3,019 3,144 2,869 3,198 111%
Wisconsin
Year 12,445
Year 23,019
Year 33,144
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years2,869
Total # Records3,198
Estimate Reported for Current Year111%
Wyoming Green Circle - No Flag 961 1,051 1,005 1,006 1,174 117%
Wyoming
Year 1961
Year 21,051
Year 31,005
Avg # Records Reported over Previous 3 Years1,006
Total # Records1,174
Estimate Reported for Current Year117%

No Flag

Estimated Reported is >= 50%

Red Flag

Estimated Reported is < 50%

Insufficient Data

State has < 15 records reported in current timeframe AND State has < 15 records reported in previous 3 year average AND Estimate Reported is <= 50%

Data Source: MCMIS non-fatal crash records for 12 months (plus 36 months prior average) representing interstate and intrastate carriers, and includes large trucks and buses.
A&I Online Email Subscription Service
Email (required):
First Name:
Last Name:
Check which modules you are currently using: